When Congress enacted the Petroleum Marketing Practices Act, the concern was to prevent arbitrary or discriminatory discontinuance of franchise agreements. The Act gives the franchisee various rights and allows the franchisee to maintain civil actions against any franchisor who violates the Act.

There is a federal law called the Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA) that outlaws discrimination on the basis of disability in “places of public accommodation.” See 42 U.S.C. § 12181(7). The general question that the courts have been struggling with is whether a website is a "place" of public accommodation.

If a San Diego employer violates these meal break laws, employees can file suit and recover the statutory penalties, which are one additional hour of pay at the employee's regular rate of compensation for each work day that the meal period is not provided. In general, this is called the "meal break premium." The meal break premium is due whether or not the employee makes a demand for it.

In general, the covenant does not prevent a franchisor from exercising rights that are expressly provided for in the franchise documents. It is essential to have an experienced San Diego corporate attorney review your franchise agreements to provide advice and counsel.

The CCPA provides consumers with various rights with respect to the data and personal information that is collected on them by businesses operating here in the Golden State. Violation of the CCPA could be very costly. The CCPA allows for the imposition of statutory civil penalties of up to $7,500 per violation per consumer. Even a few violations could result in substantial fines and penalties. The CCPA is a complex and confusing statute.

In a recent case involving unpaid wages, a former employee attempted to use the legal theory of conversion to sue the owners for unpaid wages. See Voris v. Lampert, Case No. S241812 (Cal. Supreme Court August 15, 2019). As a matter of law, a conversion claim can be made against the individual owners and also allows for the imposition of punitive damages against the owner.

In June 2019, Tom Brady filed for a trademark registration for the phrase "Tom Terrific." According to news reports, Brady claimed that he did not like the nickname and that he "... wanted to make sure no one used it, because some people wanted to use it." See USA Today report here. Brady filed an application with the US Patent and Trademark Office ("USPTO") for use of the trademark with respect to t-shirts, football-related memorabilia, and sports collectibles.

A "representation" is a legal word meaning "statement of truth," and a "warranty" indicates that the statement can be relied upon and that, if the statement is false, a lawsuit can be filed seeking damages for the falsity of the statement. Among the advice and counsel that can be provided concerns the representations and warranties, read the article for a list of typical examples.

In today's business environment, four years is a long time and represents a substantial financial risk. As many know, litigation is expensive. Best business practices argue in favor of reducing financial risks by eliminating -- as far as is allowed by California law -- potential lawsuits that may be buried in the "contracts completed" drawer of the filing cabinet. Among the best methods to accomplish this risk-reduction is to truncate the statute of limitations through contractual agreement

Your San Diego business needs a toll-free number if the CCPA applies to your business. More businesses will be subject to the CCPA than you might think. Even a small business -- say only $5 million in revenue -- could be subject to the Act.

One excellent way of reducing the risk of litigation is to only use well-drafted and clear business contracts. A well-drafted and clear contract is not merely about the words used in the contract, but also about the negotiations that lead up to the written contract and whether the contract anticipates potential real-world problems that might occur with respect to the unique situation subject to the contract.

Are you thinking of finally starting that business you have been thinking about? Are you finally going to "make the jump" from employee to owner? The first step is to incorporate. You have a few good options for forming a corporate entity here in California including a standard corporation, a limited liability company, a California professional corporation (for various types of licensed professionals) and others.

Another way that trademarks can be lost is through what is called "naked licensing." "Naked licensing" occurs when you allow others to use your San Diego trademark but do not exercise any control over how and when your trademark, logo, slogan, etc., is used.

Cumulative Rights are any specific right or remedy provided in a contract will not be exclusive but will be cumulative of all other rights and remedies. . Under older legal principles, cumulative remedy clauses were essential because often a contract would specify the remedies that a party might have in the event of a default and, then, courts would deem the listed remedies to be exclusive.

California courts will enforce such clauses, particularly when the clause is subject to actual negotiation between sophisticated parties. If a clause like this is located in a consumer contract, courts will be more exacting in evaluating whether the consumer had meaningful notice of the venue choice.

Per the statute, all corporations must comply, and failure to meet the quotas can result in statutory penalties imposed of up to $100,000 for the first violation and $300,000 for subsequent violations. According to figures released by the California Secretary of State, the act applies to over 500 corporations.

Fingerprinting and facial recognition software are probably the most commonly used biometric data. Many smartphones use facial recognition as a method of locking the phone. That data is stored and privacy advocates are concerned about where that data is stored, the security of that storage, and what other used can be made of the data.

So, what happens if someone forgets to date a document or contract? In simple terms, the parties involved will have to provide evidence of the date of the document from other sources.

Standing is a legal requirement that must be met before a plaintiff can bring a lawsuit and the plaintiff must prove that standing exists. Tightening up the requirements for standing means that fewer lawsuits will be filed which, as noted, can be good for San Diego businesses.

In general, the ADA applies to "places" of "public accommodation" and discrimination based on a disability is prohibited in such places. When the ADA was enacted, there was no internet as it exists now and, as such, the statute did not address -- and still does not address -- whether the internet is a "place of public accommodation."

With startup companies, it is not unusual for there to be a person (or persons) designated to sit on the board of directors who is given the status of "board observer." Venture capitalists and other types of investors commonly seek to have a person affiliated with their investment company placed on the board either as an actual voting member or as an observer.

Under California law, mutual agreement or assent is a necessary element of contract formation. That is, without an agreement, there can be no contract. Under case law and under the California Civil Code, assent may be "manifested" by written or spoken words or by conduct. This is one reason that most contracts are signed.

Non-disparagement clauses in business-to-business contracts have become more and more common. Where a contract is subject to back-and-forth negotiation, non-disparagement clauses are enforceable and important. These clauses are typical in business purchase/merger agreements, shareholder agreements, commercial and office leases and, increasingly, in vendor and supplier contracts.

A buy-sell agreement is essential for small San Diego closely-held corporations. Sometimes a buy-sell agreement is a stand-alone document; often the buy-sell provisions are part of a larger Owners Agreement that sets out the various duties, obligations, and restrictions related to ownership and management of the company. However, whether stand-alone or part of a larger agreement, it is important to seek the advice and guidance of an experienced San Diego corporate attorney when considering what needs to be in a buy-sell agreement.

More Problems With Off-the-Internet Form Contracts: Revisions Affect Validity and Proof Using off-the-internet form contacts is dangerous, particularly if you are running a business. It is essential to retain an experienced San Diego corporate attorney who can ensure that your business contracts are validly formed and enforceable by the [...]

In brief, the answer is "yes" assuming that you had the opportunity to review the contract and seek out a translation or a translator. Generally speaking, parties are not required to translate a contract into another language for the other party. Parties are expected to use their own resources to read, translate, and understand a contract before agreeing to and signing it.

Dynamex Retroactive? US Ninth Circuit Says: “Let's Ask the California Supreme Court” We wrote recently about the US federal Ninth Circuit's decision in Vazquez v. Jan-Pro Franchising International, Inc., 923 F.3d 575 (9th Cir. May 2, 2019). In that decision, the federal judges on the Ninth Circuit held that [...]

Even if you are unaware of the fact, your San Diego business has trade secrets that are entitled to legal protection under both California and federal law. However, certain steps must be taken to protect the secrecy of your trade secrets. If you post an online video showing how to make your "special sauce," for example, the secret is out and there is no longer a trade secret to be protected. This is what happened with the special sauce that is on the Big Mac sandwich.

The California Court of Appeals recently affirmed a trial court ruling that a restaurant did not have to reimburse employees for slip-resistant shoes. The court held that the slip-resistant shoes were not a "necessary expenditure" in the sense of being part of a unique uniform mandated by the restaurant employer

For a San Diego business contract to be formed -- to be enforceable in our courts -- the parties must come to an agreement. Most often, "agreement" is indicated by a signature or, with online contracts, by clicking on the "I agree" box. There are other methods of showing "agreement." One can indicate agreement with a contract by signing a different document, one that relates to and refers to the contract in question. That is one of the legal lessons from the recent California Supreme Court decision in Monster Energy Co. v. Schechter, Case No. S251392 (Cal. Supreme Court July 11, 2019).

There are many benefits to allowing assignability in many circumstances. So there is no reason to always say "no" to allowing assignment. However, there are legal and practical issues to consider and you should seek advice and guidance from an experienced San Diego corporate attorney. Here are some of the considerations.

In part one of this series, we discussed pitfalls and problems with respect to backdating a contract among sophisticated parties. With sophisticated business parties and where the contract has been negotiated, backdating can be "okay," but there are pitfalls to avoid.

There are some circumstances in which parties to a contract want to use a date on a business contract that is prior to the date that the contract is actually signed. This is the general meaning of "backdating a contract." As between sophisticated business parties and when the issue of the contract date is fully negotiated, backdating is not illegal.

The Federal Drug Administration ("FDA") joined a growing list of federal and state agencies that are intending to punish companies and businesses that pay social media influencers without fully disclosing the relationship and the payments.

Effective January 1, 2020, San Diego and California employers will have to be careful about their grooming and business professionalism policies and procedures with respect to hair types and styles.

With longer business contracts, there is a potential for conflict between the provisions in the contract. Indeed, the more provisions and the more pages, the more likely there may be a conflict among the provisions in the contract. This is the reason that it is important to retain an experienced San Diego corporate attorney to review and customize your business contracts.

In general, corporations are governed by their bylaws. The bylaws are adopted by a vote of the shareholders when the corporation is formed and, generally speaking, the shareholders can change the bylaws at any time by a vote of the controlling shareholders. However, there are some limitations.

One of the most important reasons to use written contracts for your San Diego business is the ability to use the contract to help eliminate risks in the event of breach. Generally speaking, the measure of damages for breach of contract here in the Golden State is "benefit of the bargain."

Last year, the California Supreme Court decided the case of Troester v. Starbucks Corporation, 5 Cal. 5th 829 (2018). In Troester, the court broadly held that the California Labor Code required that workers must be paid for all time worked, even for required tasks that only take a minute or two each day.

Every San Diego business that has employees should consider having an employee handbook. There are many state- and federally-mandated notices that must be provided and a host of company policies that must be summarized for your existing and new employees.

San Diego Business Contracts: The Difference Between an Indemnity and Damages Cap Without the assistance of an experienced San Diego corporate attorney, it can be difficult to distinguish different parts of a business contract. For example, many confuse the legal meaning and purpose of an "indemnification" clause, particularly if [...]

"Intellectual property" includes assets like trademarks, patents, and copyrights but also includes trade secrets. Indeed, trade secrets are the most common form of intellectual property owned by California businesses. Intellectual property is protected under both California and federal law.

San Diego Earn Out Provisions: Tips on Avoiding Post-Acquisition Litigation When a small-to-medium sized San Diego business is acquired by another business, often the new owners want to retain the previous owners in an employment capacity. This can be beneficial to both sides of the bargain. The new owners [...]

The US Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals recently affirmed that knowingly including inaccurate information in your copyright application will result in your copyright being held invalid. See Gold Value International Textile, Inc. v. Sanctuary Clothing, LLC, Case No. 17-55818 (US 9th Cir. June 4, 2019). The case provides an example where seeking the advice and counsel of an experienced San Diego corporate attorney during the copyright application process would have helped achieve a more desirable result.

Trade and service marks are some of the most powerful tools that a San Diego business can use to protect and expand its market share. The process of establishing a trade/service mark is essentially one of creation and use. Once in use, the mark can be registered with the US Patent and Trademark Office ("USPTO") under the provisions of the federal Lanham Act. An experienced San Diego corporate attorney can help with the legal requirements and the registration process.

Under California law, the simple answer is, “Yes, you can have a perpetual contract.” The more complicated answer is, "Yes, if that is what the parties agree to and they express that intent unambiguously in the contract." An experienced San Diego corporate attorney can help draft your business contracts to reflect what you and your contracting partners want with respect to termination.

The US District Court up in San Francisco recently handed down a decision with respect to an Uber user on the issue of contract formation.

San Diego Business Contracts: Using Insurance Clauses can Help Avoid Litigation and Reduce Costs/Risks The main function of business contracts is to set out the mutually-agreed obligations of the parties. Business contracts can also be used for secondary and tertiary purposes including reducing the likelihood of litigation and the [...]

Buying goods and services off the internet has become commonplace. But extreme caution is in order with respect to using and buying form/template contracts offline. Bluntly, it is just not a good idea and making a mistake will be expensive both in terms of a potential loss of your bargain and litigation costs if there is a lawsuit.

In general, San Diego businesses and consumers can only be bound to a contract if they agree to the contract. This is the essential element of entering into a contract knowingly. With online contracts -- like a website Terms of Service Agreement -- consumers often argue that "I did not know I was agreeing to anything."

Most contracts are enforceable as written and, once entered into, failure to perform one's obligations can lead to a lawsuit. However, there are a few circumstances in which a party may rescind a contract. Rescinding is like revoking the contract. As California Civil Code section 1688 states: "A contract is extinguished by its rescission." (Civ. Code, § 1688.) Rescission of contract is governed by California statutes.

What is "Conspicuous?": Guidance From the Federal Trade Commission With respect to certain types of consumer contracts and various types of notices, California statutes and case law often impose the requirement of "conspicuousness." As an example, if you have a provision in your website Terms of Service that requires [...]

As many San Diego employers know, in April 2018, the California Supreme Court changed the test for when a worker is to be classified as an "employee" or an "independent contractor." The new test is called the "ABC test" and essentially makes most workers "employees" here in the Golden State.

A US federal judge has recently ruled -- again -- that buying a condominium unit is not buying a "security" as defined by the California Corporate Securities Law of 1968.

Buy-sell Agreements are essential for San Diego businesses. This is true whether the business is a general partnership, a small closely-held corporation, a limited liability company, or another corporate form. A buy-sell agreement sets the terms and conditions under which the ownership of a business can be sold or transferred. The goal of a well-drafted buy-sell agreement is to provide the owners with "exit strategies" and to limit the expense of litigation when the need for "exiting" is looming.

In good news for San Diego businesses facing lawsuits about website accessibility, at least one court has recently dismissed a case because corrective actions were completed. As we have discussed before, blind and deaf users of internet websites have filed numerous lawsuits alleging that various websites are inaccessible, in violation of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”).

San Diego Corporations: Commercial and Election Chatbot Statute In September 2018, the California State Assembly passed a chatbot disclosure law (SB-1001). Then-Governor Brown signed the law, and it goes into effect on July 1, 2019. Essentially, the law requires that a website disclose to the user whether the user [...]

The legal concept of "ratification" is most commonly raised and used with respect to contracts. However, the doctrine of ratification also has application in the corporate world. An experienced San Diego corporate attorney can provide advice and guidance with respect to corporate ratification.

. In this article, we begin a series of articles describing the "parts of a contract." Let us assume, for example, that you hire an experienced San Diego corporate attorney to form a California professional corporation for you and your professional partners. As part of that process, you may want one or more agreements among owners to detail the understandings among you and your colleagues with respect to how the California professional corporation will be run, payment and bonus structures, buy-sell provisions, and more.

San Diego Asset Purchases and Avoiding Successor Liability: "Adequate Consideration Paid" is "Fair Market Value" In general, under California law, if a person or business buys the assets of corporate entity, the purchaser does not assume any of the liabilities or obligations of the selling corporation. This is the [...]

Business contracts can be confusing at times. That is one reason that is important to consult an experienced San Diego corporate attorney to review contracts that you are being asked to sign, and/or to draft contracts that you want to present for signature. One confusing aspect of business contracts is the difference between an "amendment" and an "addendum" to a contract.

In general, for a contract to be binding and enforceable, a person or San Diego business must consent to the contract. In other words, a person or business must agree to be bound. However, it is possible for a person or business to agree-after-the-fact. This is called "ratification" of a contract.

Personal brands are just like all brands -- they identify you as a unique commercial source of whatever goods or services or creative innovations in which you specialize. Part of the rise of personal brands is driven by the rise of the freelance labor market. Brands help you market, apply your skills creatively, engage with your existing and potential customers, and supercharge the growth of your market share

Every San Diego business with employees needs to have an employee handbook. An experienced San Diego corporate attorney can help draft the contents of your employee handbook and can offer advice and counsel with respect to what should be included and what mistakes to avoid.

Joint employer situations are common in today's marketplace. Joint employer circumstances are driven by several factors. First, San Diego businesses have long been using temporary staffing and flex-schedule agencies to find workers to fill work gaps left by full-time employees.

In general, when your San Diego business enters into a contract, the obligations that are imposed are the ones written in the contract -- the obligations to which the parties have agreed to bind themselves. Normally, if something is not written in the contract, then neither party is bound to that obligation. There are, however, a few exceptions to the rule where, by action of California law, certain obligations are implied.

A recent California Court of Appeals decision reaffirms that the duty to defend under a contractual indemnity clause is immediate. See Centex Homes v. R-Help Construction Company, 32 Cal. App. 5th 1230 (Cal. App. 2nd Dist. March 11, 2019).

Solving the "Liquidity Problem" is One Key to a Successful Business Divorce When you start your San Diego business with colleagues and friends, everyone hopes that the business will succeed and the friendships will last forever. Sadly, this is not always the case. For various reasons, business partners and [...]

"Materiality" Not Relevant When Contract Specifies Grounds for Termination As a general rule under California law, a breach of contract must be a "material" breach. That is, the breach must be important and relevant to the core purposes and intents of the contract. As an example, assume there is [...]

What is a Compliance with Law Provision and Why do I Need it in My San Diego Contracts? A "compliance with laws" provision requires that both parties to a contract must comply with the applicable laws with respect to some core aspect of the contract. These types of provisions [...]

What is a Writ of Attachment? A writ of attachment is a mechanism that San Diego business owners can use when a lawsuit has been filed to help collect on debts and ensure that monies are available from the debtor when a judgment is obtained. In this respect, a [...]

Consumer Privacy Act: Could the Courts Expand the Private Right of Action Under the CCPA? It has recently been reported that the California Senate failed to pass Senate Bill 561 which would have allowed a broad private right of action to consumers in the event of violation of the [...]

San Diego Commercial Leases: Who Pays if The HVAC Goes Out? Who pays if the HVAC — heating, ventilation, and air conditioning — stops working depends on what was negotiated in the lease. Repairing or replacing an HVAC system can be very expensive. Consequently, you should have an experienced [...]

Am I Bound by a Contract That I Signed Even if I Did Not Read it? In brief, "yes." A person who signs a contract is bound by the contract even if the person does not read the contract before signing. As discussed below, this applies to any contract [...]

Piercing the Corporate Veil to Reach Assets of Non-Shareholders Generally, forming a San Diego and California corporation will provide a shield against a creditor attempting to reach the personal assets of the shareholders of the corporation. In general, a shareholder of a corporation is not personally liable for the [...]

What is a "Corporate Opportunity"? If you are a major shareholder or owner of a corporation or limited liability company, you owe certain fiduciary duties to your company and to the other owners. One of the fiduciary duties that is owed is the duty to not divert corporate opportunities [...]

Pro-Tips (Part 3) for a Good Company Telecommuting Policy: Data Security If your San Diego business allows or is contemplating allowing work-from-home or other remote employees, your business must establish an official company telecommuting policy. There are a host of legal and labor law issues that must be addressed. [...]

Does Your Letter of Intent Have a Copeland v. Baskins Robbins Problem? Under California law, letters of intent are problematic and should be signed only after careful review and counsel from an experienced San Diego corporate attorney. Businesses often use a letter of intent as a method of listing [...]

Corporate Governance: Breaking Board Deadlocks with a Provisional Director Like any human activity, running a business can be fraught with disagreements and disputes. Sometimes these disagreements are severe enough to result in deadlocks on the corporation's board of directors. This is possible if your corporation has an even number [...]

Pro-Tips (Part 2) for a Good Company Telecommuting Policy: Safety and Workers’ Comp In part one of this series, we discussed how to write a well-considered and effective company telecommuting policy with respect to meal and rest breaks. Even if you have employees who work from home or otherwise [...]

What to do if a Contract is Lost or Destroyed? Sometimes it happens that a contract gets lost or is destroyed. The contract might not be filed properly among your business records, or the contracts might have not been boxed up during the most recent relocation, or the box [...]